The remuneration of the captive insurance can be arrived at by considering the arm’s length profitability of the captive insurance by reference to a two staged approach which takes into account both profitability of claims and return on capital. The first step would be to identify the captive insurance’s combined ratio. This can be determined by expressing claims and expenses payable as a percentage of premiums receivable. The benchmarked combined ratio achieved by unrelated insurance companies indemnifying similar insurance risks can be identified. The benchmarked combined ratio can then be applied to the tested party’s claims and expenses paid to arrive at an arm’s length measure of annual premiums and thus underwriting profit (premiums receivable less claims and expenses). The second step is to assess the investment return achieved by the captive insurance against an arm’s length return. This step requires two further considerations: (a) the amount of capital held by the captive insurance, and (b) to the extent to which the captive insurance invests in controlled investments (e.g. intra-group bonds, loans, etc.), the rate of investment return achieved by the captive insurance on those investments. The sum of underwriting profit from step one and investment income from step two gives total operating profit (see Section B.5 of Chapter III on multiple year data).
TPG2020 Chapter X paragraph 10.220
Posted on |
By OECD
Category: OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017) | Tag: Captive insurance, Combined ratio and return on capital, Financial transactions, Pricing captive insurance
« Prev |
Next » Related Guidelines
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.221It is important to recognise that the capital adequacy requirements of a captive insurance are likely to be significantly lower than an insurer writing policies for unrelated parties. This factor should be considered and, if necessary, adjusted for in order to determine the appropriate level of capital to use when...
- TPG2022 Chapter II Annex II example 1580. Company A, resident in Country A, and Company B, resident in Country B, are members of an MNE group. Both companies undertake the design and manufacturing of products and their activities in this regard are highly integrated. Additionally, Company A and Company B are responsible for the marketing and...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.203Insurance also requires risk diversification. Risk diversification is the pooling of a portfolio of risks by which the insurer achieves an efficient use of capital. Large commercial insurers rely on having sufficiently large numbers of policies with similar probabilities of loss to allow statistical laws of averages to apply and...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.222Where a captive insurance is used so that the MNE group can access the reinsurance market to divest itself of risk through insuring risk outside the MNE group, whilst making cost savings over using a third party intermediary, by pooling risks within the MNE group, the captive arrangement harnesses the...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.214A reinsurance captive is a particular type of captive insurance which does not issue policies directly but operates as a reinsurance under an arrangement known as “fronting”. Captive insurance may not be able to underwrite insurance policies in the same way as traditional insurance companies. For instance, certain insurance risks...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.200In order to consider the transfer pricing implications of a transaction with a captive insurance, it is first necessary to identify the commercial or financial relations between the associated enterprises and the conditions and economically relevant circumstances attaching to those relations in order that the actual transaction is accurately delineated....
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.215In accurately delineating fronting arrangements, the same principles stated for captive insurance apply. It is important to note, however, that fronting arrangements represent particularly complex controlled transactions to price as they involve the participation of a third party that is indifferent to the levels of the price of the insurance...
- TPG2022 Chapter II Annex II example 1259. Company A, resident in Country A, Company B, resident in Country B, and Company C, resident in Country C, are members of an MNE group. Companies A and B undertake the design and manufacturing of products and their activities in this regard are highly integrated. Additionally, Company A and...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.213In many cases, outsourcing certain aspects of the underwriting function would be inconsistent with the minimum regulatory standards required to operate an insurance business. However, in those situations where the captive insurance is permitted to outsource some of the activities that constitute the underwriting function (for instance, a captive insurance...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.220The remuneration of the captive insurance can be arrived at by considering the arm’s length profitability of the captive insurance by reference to a two staged approach which takes into account both profitability of claims and return on capital. The first step would be to identify the captive insurance’s combined...