Germany vs “Shipping Investor Cyprus”, November 2021, Bundesfinanzhof, Case No IR 27/19

Posted on | By Courts of Germany | No comments
Category: General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR), Tax Avoidance Schemes, Tax Treaty Interpretation | Tag: , , , , , , , , ,
« | »

“Shipping Investor Cyprus” was a limited liability company domiciled in Cyprus. In the financial years 2010 and 2011 it received interest income from convertible bonds subject to German withholding tax. “Shipping Investor Cyprus” had no substance itself, but an associated company, also domiciled in Cyprus, had both offices and employees.

The dispute was whether “Shipping Investor Cyprus” was entitled to a refund of the German withholding tax and whether this should be determined under the old or the new version of Section 50d(3) of the German Income Tax Act (EStG).

The court of first instance concluded that “Shipping Investor Cyprus” claim for a refund was admissible because the old version of the provisions in Section 50d (3) EStG was contrary to European law. The tax authorities appealed this decision.

Judgement of the National Tax Court

The National Tax Court found that a general reference to the economic activity of another group company in the country of residence of the recipient of the payment was not sufficient to satisfy the substance requirement. According to the court, the lower court had not sufficiently examined whether the substance requirements of Section 50d (3) EStG – in its new version – were met. On this basis, the case was referred back to the lower court for a new hearing.

 

Click here for English translation

Click here for other translation

BFH-Urteil-I-R-27-19

Related Guidelines

TPG2022 Chapter I paragraph 1.70Assume that an investor hires a fund manager to invest funds on its account. Depending on the agreement between the investor and the fund manager, the latter may be given the authority to make portfolio investments on behalf of the investor on a day-to-day basis in a way that reflects...
TPG2022 Chapter I paragraph 1.111To eliminate currency risk, the reference security for determining the risk-free rate would need to be a security issued in the same currency as the investor’s cash flows, i.e. the functional currency of the investor rather than its country of domicile. When there are multiple countries issuing bonds in the...
TPG2022 Chapter VII paragraph 7.10The following are examples of costs associated with shareholder activities, under the standard set forth in paragraph 7.6: a) Costs relating to the juridical structure of the parent company itself, such as meetings of shareholders of the parent, issuing of shares in the parent company, stock exchange listing of the...
TPG2022 Chapter VII paragraph 7.65The levying of withholding taxes on the provision of low value-adding intra-group services can prevent the service provider recovering the totality of the costs incurred for rendering the services. When a profit element or mark-up is included in the charge of the services, tax administrations levying withholding tax are encouraged...
OECD COVID-19 TPG paragraph 40In determining whether or not a “limited-risk” entity may incur losses, the risks assumed by an entity will be particularly important. This reflects the fact that at arm’s length, the allocation of risks between the parties to an arrangement affects how profits or losses resulting from the transaction are allocated.23...
TPG2022 Chapter VI Annex I example 2173. Första is a consumer goods company organised and operating in country A. Prior to Year 1, Första produces Product Y in country A and sells it through affiliated distribution companies in many countries around the world. Product Y is well recognised and attracts a premium compared to its competitors,...
TPG2022 Chapter VI paragraph 6.59Group members that use assets in the development, enhancement, maintenance, protection, and exploitation of an intangible should receive appropriate compensation for doing so. Such assets may include, without limitation, intangibles used in research, development or marketing (e.g. know-how, customer relationships, etc.), physical assets, or funding. One member of an MNE...
TPG2022 Chapter VI paragraph 6.13The guidance contained in this chapter is intended to address transfer pricing matters exclusively. It is not intended to have relevance for other tax purposes. For example, the Commentary on Article 12 of the OECD Model Tax Convention contains a detailed discussion of the definition of royalties under that Article...
TPG2022 Chapter I paragraph 1.116The risk-free rate of return may be relevant, for example, as a component in calculating a risk- adjusted rate of return on an investment or as the return allocable to an investor who has provided funding but has not assumed any of the risks related to the funding....
TPG2022 Chapter VI Annex I example 926. The facts in this example are the same as in Example 8, except as follows: Under the contract between Primair and Company S, Company S is now obligated to develop and execute the marketing plan for country Y without detailed control of specific elements of the plan by Primair....

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *