Tag: Concept of ‘act’

European Commission vs. Belgium, September 2023, The EU General Court, Case No. Case T 131/16 RENV

European Commission vs. Belgium, September 2023, The EU General Court, Case No. Case T 131/16 RENV

Since 2005, Belgium has applied a tax regime under which group companies could apply for tax exemptions on excess profits. The exemption could be obtained through a tax ruling from the Belgian tax authorities if the existence of a new situation could be demonstrated, i.e. a reorganisation leading to the relocation of the central entrepreneur to Belgium, the creation of jobs or investments. Profits were considered ‘excessive’ in the sense that they exceeded the profits that would have been made by comparable independent companies operating in similar circumstances and were exempted from corporate income tax. In 2016, the Commission found that the Belgian scheme constituted state aid that was unlawful and incompatible with the single market and ordered the recovery of the aid from 55 companies that had benefited from the practice. On 14 February 2019, the General Court annulled the Commission’s decision. It found, inter alia, that the Commission had wrongly concluded that the excess profits exemption scheme did ... Read more
European Commission vs. Belgium, September 2021, The European Court of Justice, Case No. C‑337/19 P

European Commission vs. Belgium, September 2021, The European Court of Justice, Case No. C‑337/19 P

Since 2005, Belgium has applied a system of exemptions for the excess profit of Belgian entities which form part of multinational corporate groups. Those entities were able to obtain a tax ruling from the Belgian tax authorities, if they could demonstrate the existence of a new situation, such as a reorganisation leading to the relocation of the central entrepreneur to Belgium, the creation of jobs, or investments. In that context, profits regarded as being ‘excess’, in that they exceeded the profit that would have been made by comparable stand-alone entities operating in similar circumstances, were exempted from corporate income tax. In 2016, the Commission found that that system of excess profit exemptions constituted a State aid scheme that was unlawful and incompatible with the internal market and ordered the recovery of the aid thus granted from 55 beneficiaries, including the company Magnetrol International. Belgium and Magnetrol International brought an action before the General Court of the European Union seeking the ... Read more