Tag: Self incrimination

Netherlands vs "Related Party B.V.", July 2021, District Court, Case No ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2021:3382

Netherlands vs “Related Party B.V.”, July 2021, District Court, Case No ECLI:NL:RBGEL:2021:3382

In 2013 “Related Party B.V” entered into an agreement with “X BV” for the provision of transportation- and support services for oil and gas. The Dutch tax authority suspected that the parties were affiliated within the meaning of Section 8b of the Corporate Income Tax Act 1969. Decision of Court The Court decided in favor of the tax authority. Based on the documents in the case, the tax authority rightly suspected that there was an affiliation within the meaning of Section 8b of the Corporate Income Tax Act. The tax authority was therefore entitled to reasonably issue information decisions for the Vpb for 2013 to 2016 inclusive. Nemo Tenetur Principle – self incrimination “Related Party B.V” argued that it’s right not to incriminate itself had been violated because the information decision(s) had been issued to examine the possibility of imposing a fine. In this regard, the court observed that pursuant to the law a taxpayer is obliged to provide the ... Read more
Canada vs Cameco Corp, Aug 2017, Federal Court, Case No T-856-15

Canada vs Cameco Corp, Aug 2017, Federal Court, Case No T-856-15

In relation to ongoing audits regarding transfer payments, the tax authorities asked the Court to order approximately 25 personnel from Cameco Corporation and its wholly owned subsidiaries to be made available for interview regarding Cameco’s 2010, 2011, and 2012 income tax years. It was confirmed in Court that Cameco has complied with all audit requests related to the relevant years except the refused request for oral interviews. Cameco has agreed to written questioning by the Minister, but not oral interviews. The Court dismissed the application. “A compliance order…can only be issued if the Minister proves that Cameco did not comply with section 231.1 of the ITA. Cameco has provided the Minister with every opportunity to inspect, audit and examine their books, records and documents and to inspect their property. The Minister confirmed that Cameco has allowed such access, save the requested oral interviews. Cameco has not allowed the oral interviews that they had done in previous years given the numbers ... Read more