“Airline S.A.” claimed various expenses as deductible payments for intra-group services, arguing that these costs were essential and necessary within the corporate group.
However, the tax authorities determined that “Airline S.A.” had not provided sufficient documentation to demonstrate that the services were actually rendered.
“Airline S.A.” appealed to the Tax Court, contending that under transfer pricing principles—specifically the OECD Guidelines for Intra-Group Services—the key questions should be whether the services were indeed provided and whether the charges were at arm’s length.
Judgment
The Tax Court dismissed the appeal and ruled in favor of the tax authorities. The Court held that the central issue was not compliance with transfer pricing rules, but rather the absence of concrete evidence that the claimed expenses were actually incurred. To qualify as deductible, taxpayers must substantiate that the transactions took place and provide reliable documentation proving both the provision of the services and the corresponding payments.
Click here for English Translation
Click here for other translation