Where the effect of a guarantee is to permit a borrower to borrow a greater amount of debt than it could in the absence of the guarantee, the guarantee is not simply supporting the credit rating of the borrower but could be acting both to increase the borrowing capacity and to reduce the interest rate on any existing borrowing capacity of the borrower. In such a situation there may be two issues – whether a portion of the loan from the lender to the borrower is accurately delineated as a loan from the lender to the guarantor (followed by an equity contribution from the guarantor to the borrower), and whether the guarantee fee paid with respect to the portion of the loan that is respected as a loan from the lender to the borrower is arm’s length. The conclusion of an analysis of such transactions may be, taking into account the full facts and circumstances, that the evaluation of the guarantee fee should be limited to a fee on the portion that has been accurately delineated as a loan, and the remainder of the loan granted should be regarded as effectively a loan to the guarantor followed by an equity contribution by the guarantor to the borrower.
TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.161
Posted on | By OECD
Category: OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2022), TPG2022 Chapter X: Transfer Pricing Aspects of Financial Transactions | Tag: Borrowing capacity, Equity contribution, Financial benefit, Financial guarantee, Financial transactions, Guarantee fee, Loan guarantee, Treasury functions
« Prev |
Next » Related Guidelines
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.167A lender would benefit from the stronger credit rating of the guarantor (compared to the borrower’s credit rating) and/or the guarantor’s asset pool (in addition to the borrower’s asset pool), and the borrower accordingly may expect a benefit in the form of a lower interest rate. Thus, based on facts...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.159Where the effect of an intra-group guarantee as accurately delineated is to reduce the cost of debt-funding for the borrower, it might be prepared to pay for that guarantee, provided it was in no worse a position overall. In considering the borrower’s overall financial position as a result of the...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.164A borrower would not generally be prepared to pay for a guarantee if it did not expect to obtain an appropriate benefit in return. Even an explicit guarantee will not necessarily confer a benefit on the borrower; for example, banking covenants applicable to a parent or other MNE group member’s...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.165A similar issue arises in respect of cross-guarantees, where two or more entities in an MNE group guarantee each other’s obligations. From the lender’s perspective, it has access to the assets of every cross-guaranteeing entity in the event of a default by a guaranteed borrower. This potentially gives the lender...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.158From the perspective of a lender, the consequence of one or more explicit guarantees is that the guarantor(s) are legally committed; the lender’s risk would be expected to be reduced by having access to the assets of the guarantor(s) in the event of the borrower’s default. Effectively, this may mean...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.182The capital support method may be suitable where the difference between the guarantor’s and borrower’s risk profiles could be addressed by introducing more capital to the borrower’s balance sheet. It would be first necessary to determine the credit rating for the borrower without the guarantee (but with implicit support) and...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.168Likewise, the financial capacity of the guarantor to meet its obligations requires an analysis of the correlation between the guarantor’s and borrower’s businesses. In situations where the guarantor and the borrower operate under similar market conditions, an adverse market event that affects the performance of the borrower and increases its...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.177The result of this analysis sets a maximum fee for the guarantee (the maximum amount that the recipient of the guarantee will be willing to pay), namely, the difference between the interest rate with the guarantee and the interest rate without the guarantee but with the benefit of implicit support...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.155In general, a financial guarantee provides for the guarantor to meet specified financial obligations in the event of a failure to do so by the guaranteed party. There are various terms in use for different types of credit support from one member of an MNE group to another. At one...
- TPG2022 Chapter X paragraph 10.87A guarantee from another party may be used to support the borrower’s credit. A lender placing reliance on a guarantee or guarantees would need to evaluate the guarantor(s) in a similar way to that in which it evaluates the original borrower. For the lender to take a guarantee into account...