Author: Courts of Kenya

Kenya vs Delmonte Kenya Limited, January 2026, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No. E1263 OF 2024

Kenya vs Delmonte Kenya Limited, January 2026, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No. E1263 OF 2024
Delmonte Kenya, an integrated pineapple producer and exporter, argued it should be characterised as a routine cost-plus producer with residual profits attributed to foreign group entities. The Kenya Revenue Authority challenged the pricing, functional characterisation, and documentation, asserting Delmonte Kenya bore key risks and created core value. The Tax Appeal Tribunal ruled in favour of the tax authority in January 2026, rejecting the taxpayer's tested party selection and benchmarking approach ... Read more

Kenya vs Cipla Kenya Limited, May 2025, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No. E422 OF 2024

Kenya vs Cipla Kenya Limited, May 2025, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No. E422 OF 2024
Cipla Kenya Limited, a pharmaceutical distributor, reported an operating margin within the interquartile range under TNMM. The Kenya Revenue Authority adjusted the result to the median, citing comparability defects in the benchmarking study. The Tax Appeal Tribunal sided with the taxpayer in 2025, finding that where defects are explicitly identified, the authority must quantify adjustments rather than default to the median ... Read more

Kenya vs Stefanutti Stocks Kenya Limited, March 2025, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No [2025] KETAT 185 (KLR)

Kenya vs Stefanutti Stocks Kenya Limited, March 2025, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No [2025] KETAT 185 (KLR)
A Kenyan subsidiary of a South African construction group claimed deductions for expatriate salary costs totalling Kshs 46 million in FY 2013. The Kenya Revenue Authority disallowed the deductions for insufficient documentation. On remittal from the High Court, the Tax Appeal Tribunal upheld the disallowance in 2025, finding that intercompany invoices alone were inadequate without employment contracts, assignment letters, or work permits ... Read more

Kenya vs Avic International Beijing (EA) Limited, November 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case no. TAT E786 OF 2023

Kenya vs Avic International Beijing (EA) Limited, November 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case no. TAT E786 OF 2023
A Kenyan assembler of Chinese motor vehicle parts applied the resale price method to price intra-group purchases. The Kenya Revenue Authority rejected this approach, applying TNMM and assessing additional income plus withholding tax on a deemed dividend. The Tax Appeals Tribunal upheld the switch to TNMM in 2024 but reduced the withholding tax liability, finding no legal basis for part of the assessed period ... Read more

Kenya vs Ola Energy Kenya Limited, November 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case no. (Tribunal Appeal E702 of 2023) [2024] KETAT 1622 (KLR)

Kenya vs Ola Energy Kenya Limited, November 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case no. (Tribunal Appeal E702 of 2023) [2024] KETAT 1622 (KLR)
Kenya Revenue Authority issued corporation tax assessments against Ola Energy Kenya Limited covering 2011 to 2016, challenging management fees and petroleum procurement margins from related parties. The Tax Appeals Tribunal set aside all assessments in November 2024, finding they were issued in breach of the applicable statutes of limitations, rendering the substantive transfer pricing arguments moot ... Read more

Kenya vs Alliance One Tobacco Kenya Limited, September 2024, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No [2024] KETAT 1347 (KLR)

Kenya vs Alliance One Tobacco Kenya Limited, September 2024, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No [2024] KETAT 1347 (KLR)
A Kenyan tobacco company argued that full-cost-mark-up transfer pricing adjustments explained variances between its CIT and VAT declarations on export sales. The Kenya Revenue Authority challenged the adjustments due to missing documentation. The Tax Appeal Tribunal ruled against the taxpayer in 2024, finding that failure to produce the actual transfer pricing policy or sufficient supporting evidence prevented validation of arm's length compliance ... Read more

Kenya vs Cummins Car and General Limited, September 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case no. TAT E450 OF 2023

Kenya vs Cummins Car and General Limited, September 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case no. TAT E450 OF 2023
A Kenyan distributor priced related-party goods using the CUP method based on pre-relationship agreed prices. The Kenya Revenue Authority challenged the method, applying the resale price method instead due to a significant timing gap. The Tax Appeals Tribunal upheld the RPM as the most appropriate method but overturned the authority's adjustment to commission rates on an unrelated-party transaction, partly allowing the appeal ... Read more

Kenya vs Siemens Aktiengesellschaft, June 2024, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No [2024] KETAT 1040 (KLR)

Kenya vs Siemens Aktiengesellschaft, June 2024, Tax Appeal Tribunal, Case No [2024] KETAT 1040 (KLR)
Siemens Aktiengesellschaft's Kenyan permanent establishment applied a 3% net cost plus margin based on its limited-risk profile, but Kenya's Tax Appeal Tribunal upheld the tax authority's assessments in 2024, applying a benchmark median of 6.94%. The Tribunal found Siemens failed to discharge its burden of proof and ruled that allocated head office costs constituted management fees subject to withholding tax under Kenyan law ... Read more

Kenya vs Global Tea & Commodities (Kenya) Ltd, June 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case No. [2024] KETAT 1077 (KLR), APPEAL NO. 1221 OF 2022

Kenya vs Global Tea & Commodities (Kenya) Ltd, June 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Case No. [2024] KETAT 1077 (KLR), APPEAL NO. 1221 OF 2022
A Kenyan subsidiary of a UK tea trading group faced a Kshs 1.4 billion transfer pricing assessment covering 2015–2018, arising from undocumented transactions with a Pakistani related party, Tapal Tea PVT Ltd. The tax authority applied TNMM after identifying common directorship as evidence of control and classified the company's auction licence as a valuable intangible. The Kenya Tax Appeals Tribunal dismissed the appeal in 2024, upholding the assessment in full ... Read more

Kenya vs Itochu Corporation, Kenya Branch, May 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, TAX APPEAL NO. 557 OF 2022 – [2024] KETAT 709 (KLR)

Itochu Corporation's Kenya Branch argued it was a liaison office subject to TNMM with a cost-based mark-up. The Kenya Revenue Authority applied the profit split method, allocating 39% of combined profits to the branch based on functional analysis, customs data, and segment disclosures. The Tax Appeals Tribunal upheld the PSM as the most appropriate method, affirmed the 39:61 split, and dismissed the appeal, citing high integration and the taxpayer's failure to provide complete records ... Read more

Kenya vs Itochu Corporation, Kenya Branch, May 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, TAX APPEAL NO. 557 OF 2022 – [2024] KETAT 709 (KLR)

Kenya vs Itochu Corporation, Kenya Branch, May 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, TAX APPEAL NO. 557 OF 2022 - [2024] KETAT 709 (KLR)
Itochu Corporation's Kenya Branch argued it was a liaison office subject to TNMM with a cost-based mark-up. The Kenya Revenue Authority applied the profit split method, allocating 39% of combined profits to the branch based on functional analysis, customs data, and segment disclosures. The Tax Appeals Tribunal upheld the PSM as the most appropriate method, affirmed the 39:61 split, and dismissed the appeal, citing high integration and the taxpayer's failure to provide complete records ... Read more

Kenya vs Beta Healthcare International Limited, February 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Appeals No 866 of 2022 – [2024] KETAT 143 (KLR)

Kenya vs Beta Healthcare International Limited, February 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Appeals No 866 of 2022 - [2024] KETAT 143 (KLR)
Following an audit of Beta Healthcare International Limited, a Kenyan subsidiary of the Aspen Healthcare Group, the Kenya Revenue Authority applied the CUP method rather than the TNMM used by the company to determine arm's length prices. The Tax Appeals Tribunal dismissed the company's appeal in 2024, finding insufficient evidence to support its characterisation arguments and upholding the tax authority's transfer pricing methodology and additional income assessment ... Read more

Kenya vs Checkpoint Technologies Kenya Limited, February 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Tax Appeal 1181 of 2022, [2024] KETAT 114 (KLR)

Kenya vs Checkpoint Technologies Kenya Limited, February 2024, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Tax Appeal 1181 of 2022, [2024] KETAT 114 (KLR)
Checkpoint Technologies Kenya applied TNMM with a net cost plus margin of 5%, within its benchmarked interquartile range of 4.9% to 7.3%. The Kenya Revenue Authority assessed additional income, arguing the median of 5.5% should apply. The Tax Appeals Tribunal disagreed, ruling in favour of the taxpayer that any point within the arm's length range satisfies the arm's length principle under OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines paragraph 3.63 ... Read more

Kenya vs ECP Kenya Limited, November 2023, Tax Appeals Tribunal, (Appeal 614 of 2022) – [2023] KETAT 944 (KLR)

ECP Kenya Limited charged a cost-plus mark-up for data and analysis services to its associated entity ECP Manager LP, arguing its role was routine support. The Kenya Revenue Authority rejected this characterisation, citing the Managing Director's involvement in investment decisions, and applied a profit split method instead. The Tax Appeals Tribunal dismissed ECP Kenya's appeal and upheld the authority's assessment in November 2023 ... Read more

Kenya vs ECP Kenya Limited, November 2023, Tax Appeals Tribunal, (Appeal 614 of 2022) – [2023] KETAT 944 (KLR)

Kenya vs ECP Kenya Limited, November 2023, Tax Appeals Tribunal, (Appeal 614 of 2022) - [2023] KETAT 944 (KLR)
ECP Kenya Limited charged a cost-plus mark-up for data and analysis services to its associated entity ECP Manager LP, arguing its role was routine support. The Kenya Revenue Authority rejected this characterisation, citing the Managing Director's involvement in investment decisions, and applied a profit split method instead. The Tax Appeals Tribunal dismissed ECP Kenya's appeal and upheld the authority's assessment in November 2023 ... Read more

Kenya vs Seven Seas Technologies Ltd, December 2021, High Court of Kenya, Income Tax Appeal 8 of 2017 [2021] KEHC 358

Kenya vs Seven Seas Technologies Ltd, December 2021, High Court of Kenya, Income Tax Appeal 8 of 2017 [2021] KEHC 358
A Kenyan technology company purchased software from a US vendor for internal use and local distribution. The Kenya Revenue Authority assessed withholding tax on licence payments, classifying them as royalties under the Income Tax Act. The Tax Appeals Tribunal sided with the authority, but the High Court of Kenya reversed that decision in December 2021, ruling in favour of the taxpayer ... Read more

Kenya vs Dominion Petroleum Dkenya Ltd, November 2021, High Court of Kenya, TAX APPEAL NO. E093 OF 2020

Kenya vs Dominion Petroleum Dkenya Ltd, November 2021, High Court of Kenya, TAX APPEAL NO. E093 OF 2020
An oil and gas exploration company faced withholding tax assessments on deemed interest from interest-free loans, reverse VAT on imported services, and withholding tax on local services following an audit covering 2011 to 2016. The Tax Appeals Tribunal partially set aside the Commissioner's decision, prompting the tax authority to appeal. Kenya's High Court ruled mostly in favour of the tax authority in November 2021, upholding the deemed interest withholding tax assessments ... Read more

Kenya vs PE of Man Diesel, August 2021, High Court of Kenya, Income Tax Appeal No. E125 OF 2020

Kenya vs PE of Man Diesel, August 2021, High Court of Kenya, Income Tax Appeal No. E125 OF 2020
MAN Diesel's Kenyan permanent establishment contested a tax assessment of Kshs 347 million, which attributed offshore equipment supply income from MAN Germany to the PE under the force of attraction rule. The tax authority argued the income was attributable under Article 7 of the Kenya-Germany DTA. The High Court of Kenya ruled in favour of the taxpayer in August 2021, finding the offshore supply income was not attributable to the Kenyan PE ... Read more

Kenya vs Oracle Technology Systems (Kenya) Limited, June 2021, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Appeals No 149 of 2019

Kenya vs Oracle Technology Systems (Kenya) Limited, June 2021, Tax Appeals Tribunal, Appeals No 149 of 2019
Oracle Technology Systems (Kenya) Limited, a distributor of Oracle products, challenged a transfer pricing assessment for FY2015–2017 in which the Kenya tax authority applied the CUP method rather than the TNMM. The taxpayer argued its controlled transactions were at arm's length. The Tax Appeals Tribunal found the method selection inadequately supported and remanded the case to the tax authority for a proper reassessment in 2021 ... Read more

Kenya vs Kenya Fluospar Company Ltd, February 2020, High Court of Kenya, Case NO.3 OF 2018 AND NO.2 OF 2018

Kenya vs Kenya Fluospar Company Ltd, February 2020, High Court of Kenya, Case NO.3 OF 2018 AND NO.2 OF 2018
Kenya Fluospar Company Ltd faced tax authority assessments over VAT and transfer pricing concerning leased mining equipment, mining services, and management fees paid to a Jersey Island entity. The tax authorities appealed a Tax Tribunal decision to the High Court of Kenya, arguing TNMM should be replaced with the profit split method. The High Court dismissed the appeal in 2020, confirming that taxpayers, not the Commissioner, have the right to select the most appropriate transfer pricing method ... Read more

Kenya vs Unilever Kenya Ltd, October 2005, High Court of Kenya, Case no. 753 of 2003

Kenya vs Unilever Kenya Ltd, October 2005, High Court of Kenya, Case no. 753 of 2003
Unilever Kenya Limited sold manufactured goods to its related company Unilever Uganda at prices lower than those charged to unrelated domestic and export customers. The Kenyan Commissioner of Income Tax assessed additional tax on the basis that the intercompany prices were not arm's length. Kenya's High Court ruled in favour of the taxpayer in 2005, finding the Commissioner's reliance on Section 18(3) of the Income Tax Act was not validly applied ... Read more