A German corporation,”G Corp” held interests in domestic and foreign companies in the year in dispute (2005). G Corp granted loans to various subordinate companies – resident in France and the USA. These loans were mainly at fixed interest rates; instead of a fixed interest rate, an annual participation of 12.5% in the balance sheet profit of the subordinate company, limited to a maximum amount of 25% of the loan volume, was agreed as consideration for one loan. No collateral was provided. In the year in dispute, G Corp wrote off these loans against taxable profits. G Corp also transferred assets at book value to a Maltese subsidiary company, of which it was the sole shareholder, and contributed the shares in this company, pursuant to section 23(4) of the Reorganisation Tax Act applicable in the year in dispute, also at book value, to another Malta-based company in the context of a capital increase against the granting of company rights. Finally, ... Read more

In 2010, “Write-Down KG” granted a loan to its Turkish subsidiary (“T”). The loan bore interest at 6% per annum but was unsecured. In 2011, Write-Down KG decided to liquidate T. Write-Down KG therefore wrote off its loan and interest receivable from T and claimed the write-off as a tax deduction. The German tax authorities disallowed the deduction because the loan had been unsecured which was considered not to be at arm’s length. An appeal was lodged with the local tax court, which upheld the tax authorities’ position. An appeal was then made to the Federal Tax Court. Judgement of the Court The court ruled that the waiver of security for a shareholder loan may not be at arm’s length. Such a deviation from the arm’s length principle may lead to a write-off of the loan receivable and thus to a reduction in income. This reduction in income may be reversed on the basis of the arm’s length principle contained ... Read more

The German court concludes that a Cash Pool agreement must be clear and unambiguous both in substance and amount. If only a minimum and maximum interest rate has been agreed the arm’s length standard is not met. Click here for English translation Click here for other translation BUNDESFINANZHOF Urteil vom 17-1-2018 I R 74-15 ... Read more

C-GmbH was the sole shareholder of I-GmbH. In 2000, I-GmbH, together with another company, set up a US company for the development of the US market, H-Inc., in which the I-GmbH held 60 per cent of the shares. H-Inc. received equity from the two shareholders and also received a bank loan of approx. $ 1.5 million (USD), which the shareholders secured through guarantees. As of December 31, 2003, the balance sheet of H-Inc. showed a deficit not covered by equity of approx. 950,000 USD. On June 30 , 2004,  I-GmbH became the sole shareholder of H-Inc. Then the bank put the H-Inc. granted loans due. Since H-Inc. was not able to serve the bank loan, C-GmbH paid the bank. As of December 31, 2004, the balance sheet of H-Inc. showed a deficit not covered by equity of approx. $ 450,000 , which at December 31 , 2005 amounted to approx. $ 1.6 million, as at 31 December 2006 $ 2.5 million ... Read more

In this case the Korean Supreme Court concluded that the tax authorities had used transactions with different terms and conditions to price the controlled transactions. According to Article 5 (1) of the National Development and Reform Act in Korea, the TNM method can be applied only when the normal price can not be calculated by a conventional transfer pricing method, e.g. due to lack of comparable transactions. In addition, there was no proper way to adjust for the significant differences between the controlled transaction and transaction. Taxation based on the conventional transfer pricing methods may later be performed by the tax referee or the court. In fact, some cases have admitted the unlawfulness of tax disposition on the grounds of unreasonable selection of comparable transactions or lack of rational adjustment. However, if the tax assesssment is canceled in court, there will be cases where the taxation can no longer be carried out due to statues of limitations. Click here for ... Read more